The article analyzes Manchester United’s ongoing struggles, particularly following a 3-0 derby loss to Manchester City. It argues that the core issues stem from player selection and positioning rather than the tactical formation employed by manager Ruben Amorim. Key players like Bruno Fernandes are criticized for being miscast in roles that do not leverage their strengths, leading to defensive lapses and goals conceded due to individual errors. Despite some improvement in team compactness and structure, the article suggests that as long as personnel are not aligned with their optimal roles, the team will repeatedly experience issues, particularly in high-stakes matches. The commentary emphasizes the need for strategic adjustments in player deployment to enhance performance.