The article analyzes Manchester United’s struggles during the current Premier League season, emphasizing that the core issue lies with player personnel rather than the tactical system implemented by manager Ruben Amorim. It argues that despite some structural improvements in the team’s formation (3-4-2-1), the frequent mistakes in defensive situations stem from players being misaligned in their roles. Key players like Bruno Fernandes and Luke Shaw are cited as examples of individuals not performing effectively in their current positions, leading to avoidable goals against the team. The discussion underscores that unless personnel issues are addressed, including better alignment with player strengths, similar defensive lapses will continue, irrespective of tactical setup. The overarching theme conveys the need for managerial recognition of player capabilities for improvement.